kill-ai-slop

Kill AI Slop

AI slop is ugly in a specific way: it piles on every possible style and detail without settling on a focus. A gradient, a glow, a mascot, emoji, a wall of glowing cards, every default switched on at once, until every product looks like the same garish template. It reads as "designed" in a thumbnail and falls apart the moment anyone looks. Your job is to strip it back to something a person would actually choose.

The principles, held on every fix you make:

1. Decide before you decorate. Every visual choice must be explainable.
2. One accent, one voice.
3. Hierarchy from scale and space. Coloring words or swapping fonts is a shortcut.
4. Subtract first. The first move toward not-ugly is removing things.
5. Specific beats punchy in copy.
6. Decoration must mean something — icons, badges, callouts are signals.

Workflow

Follow these steps in order. Do not mass-edit before the user has seen the report.

1. Scope

Confirm what to scan. Default to the app/site source (skip node_modules, dist, build, .git, vendor, lockfiles, minified files). Ask if the project mixes several apps.

2. Scan

Run the bundled scanner, which greps the codebase for the code-level signals of each tell and prints grouped file:line hits:

node scripts/scan.mjs <root>          # human-readable report
node scripts/scan.mjs <root> --json   # machine-readable, for triage

It is pure Node (no dependencies) and never edits files. Use its output as a starting map, not gospel — confirm each hit by reading the code.

To narrow a scan: --only=01,06 / --skip=19 filter by tell id, and --exclude=legacy drops paths (substring match on the project-relative path). --rules=extra.mjs loads additional project- or language-specific tells (scripts/rules.ru.mjs is a shipped Russian-copy example and the template for your own). Hits the user has confirmed as intentional can be pinned in source with deslop-ignore, deslop-ignore-next-line 06, or deslop-ignore-file comments — prefer the id-scoped forms so new tells still surface.

3. Triage

For every hit, open the file and decide slop vs. intentional. This is the step that separates this skill from a lint rule. A gradient, a serif, or an emoji can be a real, defended choice. Keep anything the user clearly chose (brand tokens, a logo, a deliberate illustration). Flag only defaults.

Read references/taxonomy.md for what each tell is and why it reads as machine-made, and references/detection.md for the exact patterns and their common false positives.

4. Report

Before changing anything, give the user a grouped summary: each tell, the file:line hits you confirmed, one sentence on why, and the proposed fix. Mirror the format:

slop  src/Hero.tsx:12   indigo→violet gradient        → one solid accent
slop  src/Hero.tsx:31   gradient-clip headline        → solid ink, scale up
slop  src/Note.tsx:8    border-l-4 callout ×3         → 1 aside, rest is body
slop  copy.md:1         "not just X — it's Y"         → say the specific thing
→ 4 groups, 11 hits.

Then ask which groups to apply, or whether to proceed on all.

5. Fix

Apply the minimal change that removes the tell while preserving intent and function. Use references/fixes.md for the before→after pattern per tell.

• Prefer editing shared tokens/components over touching every call site.
• Never invent new brand colors; if a palette must change, propose neutrals + the project's existing accent and let the user confirm.
• Keep copy meaning; make it specific, don't just delete it.
• Re-run the scanner after fixing to confirm the count dropped, and note any hits you intentionally left (with the reason).

Guardrails

• Respect authorship. Treat unfamiliar files and deliberate flourishes as someone's choice. When unsure whether something is slop, ask — don't strip it.
• Small, reviewable diffs. Never reformat unrelated code. Never run git add -A; stage explicit files only, and leave others' work-in-progress alone.
• No new dependencies to do this work.
• Verify visually when possible. If a dev server exists, look at the before and after; a passing scan is not the same as a better page.

References

• references/taxonomy.md — the 35 tells: what each is, why it's slop, the fix.
• references/detection.md — concrete ripgrep/regex patterns + false positives.
• references/fixes.md — before→after remediation patterns.
• scripts/scan.mjs — the dependency-free scanner.