mcpField
R
review

review

github.com/poemsweProductivity13585 installsUpdated 2d ago
Repository

About review

A peer-review skill for evaluating research manuscripts and proposals. It examines contribution, methodology, reasoning, and presentation, with optional adversarial or constructive framing.

Key features

  1. 01Contribution and impact assessment
  2. 02Methodological rigor critique
  3. 03Logic and conclusion checks
  4. 04Actionable revision suggestions

Use cases

  1. 01Reviewing a research manuscript
  2. 02Assessing a research proposal
  3. 03Preparing a submission for a target journal or grant

Install

Copy the command and run it in a terminal.

$npx skills add https://github.com/poemswe/co-researcher --skill review

After installing, type/reviewin Claude Code to confirm it loaded.

Details

From the project README

/review - Academic Peer Review

I'll provide a rigorous, PhD-level peer review of your research manuscript or proposal. I evaluate based on contribution, methodology, and rigor.

What I need from you:

Please provide:

  1. The draft: Paste the text or provide a link/file path.
  2. Review Type: (Optional) "Adversarial" (Reviewer 2 style) or "Constructive" (Editor style).
  3. Journal/Target: (Optional) What is your target publication or grant?

What I'll do:

  1. Initial Assessment: Significance of contribution and big-picture impact.
  2. Methodological Critique: Deep dive into the rigor and validity of your approach.
  3. Logic Check: Ensuring conclusions follow from data.
  4. Actionable Feedback: Specific suggestions for improvement.

My Review Dimensions:

  • Significance & Originality
  • Methodological Rigor
  • Argumentation & Coherence
  • Presentation & Clarity

Let's begin. Please provide the material you want me to review. Project: $ARGUMENTS

Comments

Markdown supported