touch-ipad-review

Touch & iPad review

Audit React + Tailwind apps for finger-first interaction on iPad and touch screens. Skip generic advice (use semantic HTML, be responsive, etc.) — only flag non-obvious gaps.

Checklist: references/tailwind-touch-checklist.md

When to run

User prompt like: "review app for touch/iPad usage" or "review app for this use case" with touch/tablet context.

Review workflow

1. Scan interactive UI — buttons, links, icon buttons, tabs, map controls, dropdowns / menus / Listbox, inline selectable sidebar rows, drag handles, form controls, custom click targets (onClick on non-button elements).
2. Walk the checklist — classify lists as Bucket A (Headless UI / Radix) vs Bucket B (custom <button> rows); grep helps (hover:, data-focus:, focus &&, MenuItem, ListboxOption, onClick, cursor-, group-hover).
3. Test mentally for iPad — Split View width changes, sticky hover, touch-over highlight (press-drag-release in open menus and inline lists), double-tap zoom, keyboard covering inputs, thumb reach for primary actions.
4. Emit the report using the template below — every finding must have location, issue, and concrete Tailwind/React fix.

Do not list passing generic practices. Group duplicates (e.g. "12 icon buttons missing min size") into one finding with representative files.

Report template

Copy this structure into the response:

# Touch / iPad review — [app or scope]

## Summary

[2–3 sentences: overall risk, top themes]

## Findings

### Critical

| #   | File / component | Issue | Suggested fix                   |
| --- | ---------------- | ----- | ------------------------------- |
| 1   | `path:line`      | …     | Tailwind classes or code change |

### Warning

| #   | File / component | Issue | Suggested fix |
| --- | ---------------- | ----- | ------------- |

### Nice to have

| #   | File / component | Issue | Suggested fix |
| --- | ---------------- | ----- | ------------- |

## FMC conventions verified

- [ ] All `<a>` and `<button>` (and tappable custom controls) use `cursor-pointer` on desktop
- [ ] Interactive controls use `select-none` where text selection would flash on iPad
- [ ] Hover-only affordances gated with fine-pointer media (see checklist)
- [ ] Menu/list rows: touch-over via `data-focus:` / `focus` (Headless UI) or `data-[highlighted]:` (Radix) — not `hover:` alone
- [ ] Inline sidebar pickers flagged if hover-only (Bucket B)

## Passed (non-obvious)

[Only items you explicitly checked and that are correct — keep short]

Severity

Level	When
Critical	Broken on touch, inaccessible tap, hidden functionality, mis-tap risk on primary flows
Warning	Substandard but usable; sticky hover; targets slightly small; missing feedback
Nice to have	Consistency, thumb-zone polish, haptics N/A on web

FMC defaults (always check)

Apply on every review:

Rule	Tailwind / code
Desktop pointer on links & buttons	cursor-pointer on <a>, <button>, and tappable custom controls
No iOS text-selection flash on controls	select-none on buttons, icon buttons, tabs, chips used as controls
Fine-pointer-only hover	Do not use bare hover: for essential UI; use [@media(hover:hover)_and_(pointer:fine)]:hover:… (or project variant — see checklist)

Quick grep hints

# Hover without fine-pointer guard (manual triage)
rg 'hover:' --glob '*.{tsx,jsx}'

# Small tap targets
rg '<(button|a)[^>]*(size-[0-9]|h-[0-9]|w-[0-9])' --glob '*.tsx'

# Div click traps
rg 'onClick' --glob '*.tsx' | rg -v '<button|<a '

# Missing cursor on interactives (heuristic)
rg '<(button|a) ' --glob '*.tsx' | rg -v 'cursor-pointer'

# Headless UI menus: hover without touch-over styling
rg 'MenuItem|ListboxOption|menuItemClasses' --glob '*.tsx'
rg 'hover:bg' --glob '*Menu*.tsx' --glob '*Listbox*.tsx' --glob '*Dropdown*.tsx'

# Inline sidebar rows: hover-only selection feedback
rg "hover:bg.*onClick|onClick.*hover:bg" --glob '*.tsx'

External references

• Apple HIG — Accessibility (44×44 pt targets)
• Apple HIG — Designing for iPadOS
• WCAG 2.2 — Target Size (2.5.8)
• Touch target practices (Capi Product)
• Design for Touch (Design+Code / iOS handbook)
• Mobile app design best practices (RapidNative)